Today I met a former Pakistani colleague from a basic (and man was it basic) Dutch language training course - from some 4-5 years ago. He was a PhD student then but was sufficiently gifted to get a 4 year post-grad appointment here. He was walking with his wife and kid along the street, and I made a conscious 'faux-pas' (in terms of Islamic etiquette). I shook his hand - and then hers. And I could see he was quite pissed off with me - especially as he knows that I have visited Pakistan and have some familiarity with Islamic etiquette. I figured - well hey you've been here for six years now - time to accept some western customs - women are people not chattels.
And within this brief encounter lies a dilemma for all ex-pats- to what extent should you maintain your own cultural identity and norms and to what extent should you adapt? I know that if I were to leave the NL (either to return to the UK or to move on) there would be many positive things about Dutch culture that I would miss (one example being the respect given to cyclists). Yet equally there are many things about this country that I still find annoying after six years or so - and in fact as time goes on they become more annoying- (like their small beer glasses and belief that half the glass should consist of foam).
As an ex-pat one has to strike a delicate balance between maintaining a sense of your own cultural identity (nobody loves a chameleon) and to blend into another culture. It's often not an easy balance to strike.
Monday, 1 June 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
Hi Nick,
I had a similar experience in Malaysia many years ago, but it was myself and my girlfriend that were left heartily offended.
We had been lucky enough to procure a taxi ride from KL to Penang for what, at that time, seemed a ridiculously cheap price. Certainly when compared with what a similar journey by train would have cost.
During the many hours drive in a shiny new, air-conditioned Proton, we became quite friendly with the taxi driver. He was kind enough to stop at several points of interest along the way and also contributed his own recommendations for typical Malaysian things we should do; like eating Durian fruit!
Actually his friendliness and flexible attitude made a potentially boring journey very enjoyable, and by the end of the ride we both felt very grateful and blessed to have found such an amenable man to drive us all that way.
Upon arrival in Penang, I showed my gratitude by giving our new 'best friend' a substantial tip and shook his hand heartily. My girlfriend then proceeded to offer her hand too in gratitude. Big mistake.
Well, the change in atmosphere and the stormy look on his face was instantaneous. He could not have looked more disdainful had she been proferring a freshly laid turd.
He then explained that as a muslim he was forbidden from shaking her hand but we both felt that his attitude and reaction was somewhat overblown for the situation. It left a nasty taste in both our mouths and spoiled what until then had been a very pleasant time.
My girlfriend was very hurt by the experience, and although it was essentially just a clash of values, it changed her attitude to all the muslim men she met from then on.
Now, I know that we were the strangers in a foreign land and as such were obliged to follow local custom, but this attitude just seemed so out of step with what we have come to believe in the West that it was indeed a massive culture shock.
I hasten to add that once we had been corrected in this brutal way, we made the effort to find out about local custom and our behaviour was adapted accordingly so as not to offend. Even to the point of only eating with our right hands.
It seems that your Pakistani friend has failed to adapt even after such a long time here and that can only be to his detriment. I can't believe that this would be the first time it has happened to him.
I think the well worn phrase 'When in Rome...' applies here.
Nice story Rudi did your Malysia trip inspire any breath-catching blogs ?
Yeah I know.......It's been a bit quiet of late. Just that life has been full of other stuff and I haven't had time to blog. I fully intend to catch up with everything again soon. Thanks for the nudge ;?))
Much the same with me. Blogging is on the back seat at the moment. Hope the 'stuff' has been mostly good.
the foam also bugs me I must admit - why are they so precious about it when it disappears so quickly - it'd be different with stout for example.
My biggest culture issue is paying to pee in clubs & cafes. In Watt in Rotterdam for example they charge 1 euro every time despite paying an enetrance fee. Ridiculous.
Hi Connor
Nice to see you pass by- was your thesis passed? Pay to pee annoys me sometimes too its not so bad if that means they keep the toilets clean.
I have to do a bar service at my local tennis club - which means I have to go against all my instincts and pour glasses of beer with so much foam :-(
But the good things? Or have you forgotten them?
Post a Comment