Showing posts with label supply chains. Show all posts
Showing posts with label supply chains. Show all posts

Tuesday, 5 March 2013

Working life

It’s been a long hard and cold winter. My Flemish friends noted that it snowed before St Niklaas (that’s 6th December to the rest of you). Since New Year the thermometer has barely risen above zero. The heating has stayed on at night (albeit low), otherwise it is uncomfortably cold in the morning. And the sun now rises before my alarm goes off, making it almost as redundant as the blinds in my bedroom are in keeping out light in the morning. It’s easier to get up in the light.

A few days ago I finished (editing) my first PhD thesis of the year. This one was an economics text about pineapple supply chains in Benin and how to improve them. It drew on institutional economics to describe the various supply chains and their modes of governance. These are quite familiar ideas to me – but worth explaining to many readers. In short different markets have different characteristics. There’s what people call the ‘spot market’ where things are bought and sold on the day’s trading price. Pretty much like your average fruit and veg. market (‘1 euro a kilo’) or the stock exchange. The two actually have a lot in common. They are both characterised by price volatility, opportunistic behaviour, a lack of trust between traders and what economists call ‘information asymmetry’ (one set of traders having more information than the others and using this to their – unfair- disadvantage).

On the other hand there are more structured markets, which are characterised by ‘asset specificity’. For example, you might be making a component that has very specific standards, performance etc. In this case you don’t sell on the spot market but enter into long term contracts, in which the product characteristics, pre and after sales service etc. are specified in detail. As a producer you may have to ‘tool-up’ your factory/farm and/or workforce to meet certain production criteria and need assurance that your investments will be worthwhile. Such relationships are characterised by long-term commitments and, as a general rule, the more specific the product/component – the stronger the relationship between buyer and seller. In the world of food, organic food or food with a regional origin, tends more towards the latter kind of market. For example organic coffee growers - in say Guatemala - will enter into agreements with buyers to grow in an organic manner. In return they will receive some training, perhaps some capital and a guaranteed minimum price. It’s a system that has a stabilising effect on the market and trading relations.

As individual consumers we are often bombarded with information that tries to make us ‘spot market’ buyers. In reality that is far from the case. We want a dentist, mechanic, accountant etc. whom we can trust. If they mess up, or their prices become exorbitant, then we will probably look elsewhere but the transaction (cost) of finding a new supplier – in terms of time of time if not money - can be daunting. So while we may look for the cheapest avocado we look for a reliable and trustworthy mechanic, etc.

Anyway, the point of this thesis was that pineapple growers in Benin could do much better if they were to enter into reciprocal agreements about quality, quantity, price etc. It would help them overcome the problems of not knowing who their buyers might be and also potentially offer them some access to up-front finance (pineapples have a long growing season and are capital intensive).

For my part I learned about the different characteristics of pineapple varieties, some of which (e.g. Cayenne Smooth) are in demand in northern markets, others more favoured in the countries where they are grown (e.g. Sugarloaf). To celebrate finishing this first thesis of the year I stopped by at Brussels biggest market to buy myself a pineapple. Despite the huge immigrant population in this part of town, I could only find Cayenne Smooths while my mouth was tingling remembering how good the green ones taste.

Thursday, 25 March 2010

Taking care of business

I'm generally reluctant to blog about my business. Partly because I don't want to use my blog as a marketing platform. Partly because a lot of the editing work I do is pre-publication - and it would be indiscrete to talk about the contents of reports that have not yet been published. And, sometimes, it would be betraying client confidence to grumble about the quality of texts that I am asked to heal. Some of these texts could have been generated by the Po-Mo essay engine.

As an internet-based business my work can be quite anonymous. Often I never meet the people I am working for. The opportunity to meet clients is always welcome. This week a paper I had just edited about transparency in coal supply chains was the subject of a Political Cafe in Den Haag. A good opportunity to get out of Wageningen for an evening and to meet the faces behind the e-mails.



The paper was commissioned following the Dutch government's decision to allow the deregulated power sector to construct five new coal-fired power stations in the coming years. As the Netherlands doesn't have any working mines this will imply a massive increase in coal imports. (It also implies tying the country into a high level of fossil fuel dependency over the coming forty years - with implications for meeting targets for reducing greenhouse gas emissions). The main sources of coal for the Dutch energy sector are South Africa, Colombia and Indonesia; so Both ENDS commissioned civil society organisations (CSOs) in these countries to look at the environmental, social and human rights footprints of coal mining in these countries. The results were not pretty reading (the report is still in draft format - so i won't steal their thunder by giving anything away). The CSOs found a litany of environmental neglect, pollution, health problems and civil rights abuses (the latter two among both the workforce and surrounding communities). This is perhaps not much of a surprise - any country with a coal mining industry has seen these issues played out; establishing worker's rights, health and safety regulations and pollution controls. In many ways these have been defining moments countries' political histories. Think back to Aberfan (South Wales) or the Ludlow Massacre in Colorado.

These days (with the exception of Poland) hardly any coal is mined in the EU. Instead we rely on supplies from distant countries. And this means the problems become more distant. While there is some level of awareness and concern about the exploitation in plantation agriculture and the clothing industry the social conditions and environmental effects of extractive industries(which extend far beyond coal) often remain forgotten - possibly because these are 'hidden commodities' that go into power stations, mobile phones or whatever: that we as consumers don't purchase directly.

One of the main discussion points at the meeting was the extent to which Dutch electricity companies are meeting their (voluntary) requirements on transparency and corporate social responsibility - holding their suppliers responsible for meeting basic environmental, health and safety and human rights standards. The ensuing discussion revealed a clear lack of traceability along the supply chain - with buyers not able to trace back coal shipments to their original source. The industry representative argued that this was because the complex nature of coal trading. The (largely NGO type) audience felt it reflected a lack of will among companies to follow their supply chains back to source.

This then led to a discussion about where responsibility lies in a system of multi-level governance. Does it lie with with private companies (who have made individual commitments to corporate responsibility - which may or may not be so much greenwash)? Does it lie with the industry as whole - who can set down benchmark standards. Does it lie with government - who can make companies legally responsible for the actions of their suppliers (especially those that they have a large financial stake in)? Or, in an increasingly Europeanised energy market does t lie with the EU. These issues won't be resolved by one meeting but it was an interesting and topical can of worms to open.